‘Indian Matchmaking’ vs 'A Suitable Girl'
‘Indian Matchmaking’ and ‘A Suitable Girl’ have much in common: producer Smriti Mundhra, match-maker Sima Taparia, and an overwhelming display of complex but problematic routines and notions around arranged marriage. Yet, one is cringe (but binge-worthy), while the other is deeply unsettling.
The difference in reception makes sense. ‘Indian Matchmaking’ is a reality series, featuring cosmopolitan drama of privileged and affluent late 30-somethings looking for love “the traditional way”. Banging one-liners such as ‘Marriages nowadays are like biscuits, they keep breaking’ dished out by Sima Aunty makes it a hoot. ‘A Suitable Girl’, on the other hand, is a documentary based on three educated and working women—but middle-class (yes, that matters)—looking to marry. The constant evaluation of their unsuitability, often undertaken by their own families and the ever-present unwelcome society that cares (read: pries) too much, is nothing less than harrowing. The emotional tax it levies on the self-confidence and ambitions of these women is just unforgivable.
Why is it then that the meme-worthy one-liners and blatant luxuriance of single NRIs on ‘Indian Matchmaking’ is sufficient to supersede the characters’ personal struggles with this problematic institution and come across as just funny, and not poignant?
Perhaps because the regressive, casteist, and colorist bigotry abundantly displayed there is a benign violation. (Cue to read Benign Violation Theory, if you don’t know already.)
It’s a violation because a constant assessment of one’s ‘suitability’ based on age, looks, or inherited wealth or caste, is plainly inexcusable. Period.
But this violation is benign, because aside from the taunts by pearl-clad desi NRI aunties and the public trolling willingly signed up for, our beloved ‘intimidating’ Aparnas, ‘heartbroken’ Nadias, ‘over-enthu’ Bobbies, and ‘obnoxious’ Pradyumans are going to be just fine—married or not. Their marital status will never undermine their other achievements or label them a ‘burden’.